Sunday, March 20, 2011

Shattering Beer's Glass Ceiling: The Rise of Women Brewers

“Women have always been involved in craft beer—but their ranks are growing, and they don't want to be like the boys” this is a quote that was used in the article by the name of Shattering Beer’s Glass Ceiling: The Rise of Women Brewers. After reading this article I was able to learn that there are some gender differences that create a glass ceiling for women in the real business world. In the last few years women have been trying to break the glass ceiling by attaining higher executive positions in many industries and the women in this article are not the exception. Last month three women from different breweries met in Cambridge, Massachusetts to “cook-up” their own beer in an industry that has been defined by being dominated by men and where women still face some challenges.
The article explains that even though women have been part of the craft beer renaissance since its beginnings in the 1980s, it was not until the last decade or so that women have been noticed more on the brewery floor.  It was not until the recent years that women were identified as brewers rather than just “one of the boys” in the industry. One of the questions that was asked was “what’s changing?” One of the women answered “more women are starting to realize there’s a place in the industry for them” (Parisi, 2011). Also, a corker in the quality control from one of the breweries said that it was only in the last two and a half years that he first met a woman brewer.
Megan Parisi, also explains that the culture of the industry is changing in America. She states that more women are drinking beer on their own, which is creating more awareness. But all three women also explain that there are still many differences they are facing within the industry. For example, all three women say they felt welcomed at their breweries, but they do have challenges when it comes to dealing with suppliers, distributors, and customers. Laura Ulrich, who is one of the brewers, explains about the time when she is with a group of men brewers; most people would walk up to the men and never acknowledge her presence. It seems that in fact women do face gender differences and, therefore, a glass ceiling in the beer industry. According to chapter 13th of our textbook, women face significant gender biases and social disincentives when they self-promote for leadership positions.  This industry is not the exception. The article states that women involved in brewing are still small, particularly because they exclude office staff, sales teams, and bartenders and wait staffs, which are seen more as facilitator or organizer roles rather than leadership roles. I believe the women in this article are self-promoting themselves for a leadership position and therefore making women more socially attractive and more hirable within the industry. Also, another difference is that women are trying to overcome the traits necessary to work in the industry. For example, our text book explains that men are more likely than women to have the ability to persuade and in the article it does tells us that these woman are facing problems when dealing with suppliers, distributors, and customers because women are less likely to negotiate.
I believe if women can overcome the problems dealing with their suppliers and distributors they will be able to break the glass ceiling within the industry because, as the article states, the American culture is changing and more women are trading mixed drinks for beer. I believe these three women brewers are breaking the glass ceiling by trying to show the industry that women do have what it takes to play in this “boy’s game”. Do you think we will be seeing more companies within the beer industry hiring more women as leaders? Do you think the American culture is changing within this industry?

Posted By: Hugo Sanchez

2 comments:

  1. I can see that eventually brewery's will begin to start to hire women in some of their possible positions within the company. Women have different opinions and now that they are beginning to socially drink more often their opinion is becoming even more important in order to snatch up more of the market share.

    With this change of women drinking more often this does show a major shift in american culture. Not long ago it was looked down on for women to be drinkers but now with women becoming more powerful i think that is causing there to be a shift in this industry as well. You do not want things like alcohol to be involved with someone who is supposed to be looked as the caring parent to be partaking in a lot of drinking. Now that women are not considered to be the only one taking on that role i think it is making it less looked down on for a women to have the occasional drink. This change does show that there might finally be some big break troughs coming for women in the next few years.

    You brought up a good point though and that was that women do not really self promote themselves. Laura in this situation probably did not do enough to try to talk to some of the distributors. Considering that this is now becoming an up and coming thing for women the distributors most likely did not know that she was opening her own brewery and she probably did not speak up enough to be approached or taken seriously. Women really need to begin to self promote if they want to make it to the top of businesses or become very well known in the beginning of a small business that they might be creating.

    Posted by: Jim Link

    ReplyDelete
  2. I find it difficult to discover the correlation between women drinking more or being viewed as acceptable to drink beer regularly and success in the brewery. While the two are often seen as intertwined events I think that part of the article doesn't provide much support for the author's argument. Just because a woman it is acceptable for an individual to partake in a certain activity does not correlate to success in the creation of that good or service. Overall, however, I feel that it is more of a side effect of women breaking the glass ceiling, specifically in the brewing industry. Since women are being more active and are getting more recognition in the brewing industry, their drinking beer is more widely accepted and normalized. Not the other way around.

    ReplyDelete